13 Comments
User's avatar
Josh T. Smith's avatar

I think I'd go one step further than you do on the full expensing point.

Immediate depreciation makes the tax code neutral (sometimes full expensing and IDC is one form of this).

Without immediate expensing, there's a bias in the tax system against capital investment. So, it's even better than you say because allowing full expensing is a tax neutral system.

The Tax Foundation has lots of good analysis on this point.

https://taxfoundation.org/blog/one-big-beautiful-bill-expensing-state-tax-conformity/

And some more comments here as it relates to recent improvements in US tax policy: https://www.c3solutions.org/policy-paper/the-economic-and-environmental-case-for-immediate-expensing/

Michael Magoon's avatar

Yes, I agree with you on this. Long-term economic growth requires corporate investment and the US tax code is a major disincentive. Corporate investments should be immediately depreciated.

Carpenter Morrison's avatar

is it really so foolish for lower-income countries to subsidize fossil fuels if fossil fuels' positive externalities are so large?

Michael Magoon's avatar

Ha. Good one. I guess that you got me there. I did not think of that.

Carpenter Morrison's avatar

It seems like the social surpluses from capitalist growth are so big compared to the profits enjoyed by firms/investors that we should be looking for ways to goose growth. Patents and energy subsidies seem like interesting examples. Maybe automotive infrastructure, too, since cars and buses seem so important for labor market search improvement

Foxhuntingman's avatar

Expensing of intangible drilling costs is not a subsidy. When I was in law school, everyone agreed that it was good tax policy, because requiring their capitalization would create a perverse incentive to plug wells.

Robert K Wright's avatar

Yes, I understand and agree, but by adding what consumers pay to what you say the fossil fuel industry pays -- $50 billion out of $80-90 billion -- seems to unfairly argue that the fossil fuel industry is heavily taxed when most is actually paid by consumers, not the industry.

Robert K Wright's avatar

While I don't disagree with you that there is often bias in reporting about the O&G and coal industries in the US, you seem to have gone to the opposite extreme. You are giving credit to the 'fossil fuel industry' for the fuel excise tax, paid solely by consumers, which makes up about 60% of the total that you claim the fossil fuel industry (including coal) pays to the government ($80-90 billion). If you take that out of the total paid to the government, the so-called fossil fuel industry itself is not paying a terribly large amount. And as to paying royalties to governments, the fossil fuel industry has to pay royalties and leases to private land owners for drilling and mining on their lands. What's the difference? How much do they pay to private land owners? No major companies in fossil fuels have failed that I recall. They have a pretty good deal.

Michael Magoon's avatar

Thanks for the comment, but I am not sure that understand your logic. I think that you may have misunderstood my claim. I am not claiming fossil fuel companies have a bad deal.

The central claim of this article is that Western nations do not subsidize the fossil fuels industry anywhere near as widely as claimed by Greens. Plus the taxes paid by the industries are more than even the broadest definition of subsidies.

Yes, consumers pay fuel excise tax, but it is still a tax on fossil fuel consumption. Those who use electricity from solar and wind do not pay similar excise taxes.

You are correct that fossil fuel companies pay royalties and leases to private landowners. But solar and wind producers on public land do not pay similar royalties and leases.

So in both cases fossil fuel companies are paying to the government, while solar and wind are not.

I never claimed that these taxes are unfair. I am pointing out that these tax payments that are larger than the subsidies and the net cost is far different from solar and wind.

Not sure why "no major companies in fossil fuels have failed." I never claimed that these taxes were so burdensome that it threatened their business.

Bottom line: fossil fuel are used because they are a very cost-effective source of energy. They do not need subsidies of any kind to be viable, nor do they really receive them. Greens claim the opposite.

On the other hand, solar and wind receive massive subsidies and pay few taxes.

Tris's avatar

Yes, there might be some subsidies here and there, on a specific project, on some form of fuel, in some countries (somehow many producing countries use the proceeds from their exports to subsidize domestic consumption) but simple logic show that there could not be subsidies at the global scale.

How the main source of energy that power the whole economy by far could be subsided ? Where the money would come from anyway ?

But of course, that doesn't mean that fossil fuels don't cause massive externalities with cumulative costs that we haven't yet paid...

Michael Magoon's avatar

Agreed, but if you are going to tally up the negative externalities, you much also include positive externalities, such as the massive increase of the material standard of living of millions of people. It is difficult to see how this could have been achieved without fossil fuels (although fossil fuels were necessary, but not sufficient).

https://frompovertytoprogress.substack.com/p/rapidly-phasing-out-fossil-fuels

So even when you include externalities, the total effects of fossil fuels for humanity is very positive.

Tris's avatar

Yes... same as at the restaurant. First you get the food then you get the bill 😉

Jonathan Nankivell's avatar

My four step proposal for management of the energy sector:

1. In the UK the green tax system is (breathes in) fuel duty, the climate change levy, the carbon price floor, electricity generation levy, energy profits levy, the emissions trading scheme, petroleum revenue tax and air passenger duty. There is plenty on the energy subsidy side too. This path-dependant hodgepodge is needlessly complex and in dire need of reform*. Scrap it.

2. Replace it with (1) a subsidy for energy and (2) an air pollution tax (particulates and greenhouse gases). Do this in a fiscally neutral way with respect to the current system - tweak it from there. Enter into air pollution tax treaties to ensure that goods entering from abroad are not double-taxed.

3. Reform wholesale electricity prices to reflect the real-time cost of provision. Wholesale prices should be real-time and depend on the local supply and demand. Publish live prices to an API.

4. Constrain payments are stupid. It is better to pay people to use the energy from wind farms than it is to pay them to turn the wind farms off. Incentivise consumers (industry and household) to move to real-time tariffs by offering "constraint payments" to people on the demand side too.

*For instance, the receipts from the petroleum revenue tax have are _negative_. Source: `https://obr.uk/data/` How can you lose money on a tax?