4 Comments

Two obvious comments: what about the Mediterranean republics of Antiquity? Secondly, is there any comprehensive paper where this concept is developed? Regarding Netherlands, their society was extremely urbanized even in the Middle Ages; are you sure the Italian medieval republics shall not be here? In any case, thanks for the post!

Expand full comment
author
Feb 20·edited Feb 20Author

Thanks for the comment.

Very little work that I know of discusses Free Peasant societies. That it is why it is hard to be specific about which societies apply to the term.

The only work that I know of is by Gerhard Lenski, who had a huge impact on my thinking. I believe that he used the term "Frontier society" and he focused on Biblical Israel. He saw them as a sub-type of Agrarian societies as I do.

"Frontier society" is briefly mentioned in these summaries from my online library of book summaries

https://techratchet.com/2020/02/03/book-review-human-societies-an-introduction-to-macrosociology-by-nolan-lenski/

I used to live in Denmark and I know that there has been alot written about the limited extent of feudalism in Scandinavia and its impact on modern egalitarianism. I don't think that this has been applied to other regions.

I have a post coming out on Thursday about Ancient Greece, so I will defer answering until then. I think the early Roman Republic might be an example of a Free Peasant society, but all the land and slaves from military conquests went to wealthy landowners, so I think that gradually overcame free peasants. It is clear that peasants losing their land to wealthy landowners was a key contributing cause of the frequent civil wars in the Late Republic. I have never seen a systematic study of land ownership in the Roman Republic, so at this point it is only speculation.

You are correct about urbanization in the Netherlands, but I am not sure that it applies for the period before 1500. I might be wrong, as I am not as familiar with that time period.

I think the Italian medieval republics were Commercial societies as they were heavily urbanized. This tended to make farmers far more commercialized than in a typical Free Peasant societies.

But again this concept is so underdeveloped that one good book about the subject could completely change my mind.

Expand full comment

The Agrarian History of Sweden, in 5 volumes (in Swedish) is widely considered definitive here in Sweden. English summary here.

https://www.academia.edu/31602764/The_Agrarian_History_of_Sweden_4000_bc_to_ad_2000

One important thing which was necessary for Swedish industrialisation was the abolishment of the Guild system.

Expand full comment
author

Thanks for the link. I will check it out.

Expand full comment