12 Comments

User's avatar
Kathleen Weber's avatar

Bing Copilot identifies the final step in the scientific theory as communication:

Communication: Share your findings with the scientific community for review and further testing.

I think this review is intended to be a free-ranging review by others and not a review of a tiny fragment of your findings at a time.

I fully understand that it would be quite burdensome to have to discuss your entire theory in the comments section on every single post. I think once a month is quite reasonable, however.

Expand full comment
Kathleen Weber's avatar

You have presented a general theory of history. Where and how can we discuss that in its fullness, on a regular basis, rather than a tiny fragment of it?

One of the strengths of your theory is that it is has a whole with interacting parts. I know of no other realm of intellectual discourse where there is no place to frequently discuss “the big picture.”

I think that your reluctance to entertain discussions of the big picture is a devastating weakness in introducing your ideas to the world. Those who seek to understand the world, want to freely discuss the whole of a theory. What if Columbus came back from his first voyage and told everybody that he would only discuss the ocean currents that affected his outward voyage today? He would drive everyone crazy.

I suggest that a good compromise is to put out a post once a month where any and all forms of discussion are welcome.

Expand full comment
10 more comments...

No posts