7 Comments

User's avatar
David L. Kendall's avatar

Your analysis and explanations are clear, insightful, and helpful.

In my view, economic inequality is due to a single, simple fact: humans are not clones. Humans are ontologically equal, but are unequal in every other way. Isn't it unreasonable to expect economic equality to emerge among any collection of humans that are fundamentally not equal?

Expand full comment
Swami's avatar

I agree with your psychological roots to unfairness aversion. You ask what the classical liberal response to inequality would be. My first cut at an answer (which overlaps with what you later recommend):

My Answer: Modern societies are complex systems that require extensive division of labor and specialization which requires getting the right (best?) people in the right jobs and incentivizing them to excel for the benefit of themselves and others. People differ widely in goals, desires, abilities and experience, and if given freedom and opportunity will naturally differ widely in outcome in myriads of dimensions and careers. Any attempt to force equalization will require limits on freedom and extreme coercion and will result in the decay or destruction of society and the impoverishment of humanity.

It seems to me that this answer is morally compelling. It is a bit more complex than "inequality is bad", but at least it doesn’t hinge on the leftist linguistic sleight of hand where "unequal" is substituted for "unfair", and they hope nobody notices that the two are not the same. Inequality is not the same as unfair, and even a child could grasp the difference if given half a chance. Indeed forcing equal outcomes would only be fair if we also force equal contributions, which would be cruel and totalitarian.

And this hints at the real reason the left rallies around equality (of outcome on dimensions they deem important). It is a simple and a seemingly just goal which then excuses every possible intervention in society. It is a license for control and justification for power.

Expand full comment
5 more comments...

No posts